I like both for example but some things are hard to realize on both platforms (rts like Starcraft and Dawn of War on the console), or its just the "sofa-factor" for example (i prefer to play beatemups on consoles and race game mostly too).
I think shooters are something special cause you can realy make a good one on a console, but you got a few limitations or its just easyer to realize on the PC (faster turning, by absolute accuary, without any autoaiming->alien comes to mind and as pred you can find spots to jump on much faster).
Anyway everyone got a different feel and other requirements for games or whole genres on the different platforms and all factors can explain totally opposite opinions, from #### people.
There are not many things in the world, too which all people agree.
But...Just have fun and let others think, like they do.