Quote from: Kimarhi on Jun 08, 2007, 12:50:39 AM
A guy swinging around a heavy quarterstaff or a broadsword is going to be strengthing his body. Whether he gets as strong as the weightlifter depends on how long he's willing to do only that exercise.
I will agree with a lot of what you said, BUT, adding weight increments in necessary for increasing strength.
You can get stronger by doing anything that requires the use of muscles, but swining around a broadsword all day will not enable you to Deadlift 500 pounds.
The rep range of 12 I preffer, sometimes 15, but I wold not get any stronger max by doing more reps than that.
Once I can hit a weight for 15 reps, and 3 sets of that, I NEED to increase the resistance to grow.
Different fibers are worked for endurance than pure tensile capacity.
For example you could have two guys (twins) with the exact same genetics. Both eat and sleep the same amounts.
One guy increases his weights by 0.5 pounds every time he can do 15 reps with a new weight.
The other guy does more reps.
The guy adding the weight will be significantly larger, and have a greater total tensile strength, while the second guy will have a greater endurance for a given weight.
Say the exercise is the Deadlift. Ok, both start at 225 pounds. The guy what is adding weight will eventually hit 500 pounds (with good genetics and diet), the guy doing more reps will not be able to do 500 pounds when he attempts it, regardless of how many reps is done with 225. The opposite is also true. The guy who can do 500 for only 12 reps, will not be able to do 225 for 40 reps.
It is all what you train for. The only way to get bigger is to add resistance. Regardless of the rep range.