ALIEN VS PREDATOR VERSES ALIENS VS PREDATOR REQUIEM!
acting: Alien vs predator (2004) wins best for acting straight up!
CINEMATOGRAPHY: Alien vs predator (2004) slaps requiem consistently in the face. the image quality, lighting, and in requiem is quite poor
ACTION: well for the VISIBLE scenes in requiem, i think requiem wins action, violence etc. paul w s anderson's action in alien vs predator feels "censored".
Story: ALIEN VS PREDATOR(2004) takes the win, definitely. Even though the stakes of alien vs predator, being in Antarctica is not high, (what are they gonna do, kill some penguins?), the whole temple, predator mythology is really interesting. Requiem doesn't do anything except add the predator homeworld. also avp looks expensive and it looks like anderson tried. requiem looks like the directors and people behind it didnt give a shit.
when you sum up alien vs predator: it's explorers and scientist uncover a ancient pyramid were predators kept xenomorphs' to hunt for the right of passage. the pyramid changes every 10 minutes like a never ending maze.
when you sum up requiem: a predator scout ship crash lands in a small town, unleashing facehuggers and xenomorphs. a group of annoying teenagers must try make it out the town, or die. it is literally about a couple of annoying teens running around screaming in pitch black with a few xenomorphs nocking on peoples bedroom windows and chasing people down the road.
HOW THE HELL DID AN ALIEN AND PREDATOR APEAR IN A SMALL BUDGET SLASHER FILM!!!