Post reply

The message has the following error or errors that must be corrected before continuing:
Warning - while you were reading 863 new replies have been posted. You may wish to review your post.
Note: this post will not display until it has been approved by a moderator.
Other options
Shortcuts: ALT+S post or ALT+P preview

Topic summary

Posted by StayFrosty
 - Mar 14, 2024, 01:31:14 AM
5 Neca Dog Aliens not from Fire Team Elite, all on all fours and looking pretty bad ass imho. They weren't that difficult to pose, and this is a slippery linoleum floor at that...









Posted by Neila
 - Mar 05, 2024, 08:47:24 AM
Personally, I generally have a problem with representations of the xenos in the figure area that are not film-accurate.
The industry has already come up with a lot of mutations.
there are only a few that are really good.
Strangely enough, things are completely different with Predator. There are a lot of free interpretations by sculptors that look much better than those in the film.

the dog alien, who also inspired the runners in the AVP games and Fireteam,
also has the ability to move on 2 legs. The runners actually only move on 4 legs.
The hind legs are correspondingly short while the original dog alien has quite long hind legs.
That's why I never really liked the runners because they scurry around like little rats in the games.
How cool would the original Dog Alien have been?
Most comics are pretty bad because the xenos often come across as far too massive and muscular.
This representation should remain with the predator.
a xenomorph must be wiry and slim.
The banana head must appear slightly oversized.
Mc Farlane's AR and AvP figures are pretty much the worst xeno figures I've ever seen.



Posted by BlueMarsalis79
 - Mar 05, 2024, 08:28:35 AM
Like I said I totally get that and I agree. They somehow did not make that mistake with the Prowler and Burster with the face area. (Which can be fixed with some hot water, cold water, and water texture paint.) But better the face than the whole figure for me.

Also it does come out taller than all the humans and some of the Predators that I have.

It can also run on one arm and one leg with the others in the air it is so well balanced, good luck getting "the ultimate" doing anything similar.



If a Runner figure can not do this pose then I think it does not succeed as a depiction of the main trait of it honestly, that being the posture, and elegance in that particular way of moving rather uniquely from the other Aliens.
Posted by Xenomrph
 - Mar 05, 2024, 04:17:40 AM
Quote from: BlueMarsalis79 on Mar 04, 2024, 11:52:50 AMI can get not liking the Fireteam Elite Runner figure face area, I do not love it myself, but in size terms?

It still towers over most one tenth scale figures, just not to the degree of the Ultimate one, but the pose potential, the detail, the balance, the symmetry, the sculpt and paintjob outweigh the face being somewhat weird.
(Weird that they nailed it with the Prowler and Burster)

Look at the Ultimate from above and you can see the dome's literally f**king slanted to one side, it's so awful looking, look at the legs and arms being completely alternate sculpts, or the giant ball joints at the pelvis that comes further out to one side that the other.

It is just a poor representation of my favourite Alien.

If you do not like the Fireteam Elite Runner, I totally can get the reasons behind why, but that does not therefore make the Ultimate not a total mess because it absolutely is.



Counterpoint: That's your opinion and you're welcome to it, people are allowed to like things you don't.

The face on the FTE runner isn't "somewhat weird", it's genuinely bad and doesn't look like the Alien3 runner. If you want a representation of the movie runner, the FTE one fails at that point, full stop. The Lanard Toys runner's face is more accurate than the FTE one. I think you've said the FTE toy is based on the in-game renders from FTE, but even I am willing to call shenanigans on that - I don't believe the in-game model's face looked as bad as the toy's does. But I'm willing to be wrong on that, it's been a bit since I played the game or seen direct comparisons.

The runner shouldn't tower over "most" NECA humans, it should tower over all of them. If it doesn't, the size is wrong.

I think the paintjob looks great, the FTE one absolutely is not enough of an improvement to justify buying what I see as an otherwise inferior product.

And believe me, I really like the Alien3 runner, it's one of my favorite designs too. But the Ultimate one hits all the right notes for me, it looks great, it's big, I can get it in all the poses I want, the accessories are cool, AND it was cheaper than the FTE one.

Edit--



https://www.artstation.com/artwork/qQr4RN



The toy's upper lip and jaw protrudes out more than the render does, and neither of them look quite like the one in the movie (although the render's version is substantially closer).

With Aliens, the face is the first thing my eye gravitates towards, and it's real easy to screw that up and make the whole production unappealing to my eyes. The FTE toy does this (on top of its other problems), making it an instant dealbreaker. If the face wasn't jacked up, I'd likely have bought it. Shit, I've seen it in stores as recently as like 3 weeks ago and I held it in my hands and said "do I want this?" and then I'd look at the face and say "yeah nah, the Ultimate one will do".

Of course, all of this is my opinion and preferences. You do you. :)
Posted by Neila
 - Mar 04, 2024, 01:39:26 PM
Quote from: SiL on Mar 04, 2024, 12:51:14 PM
Quote from: Neila on Mar 04, 2024, 11:17:25 AMDoes anyone remember the bonus powerloader figure from A:CM?
the attacking alien warrior is much even smaller than the marine.
I'm looking at it now and it's not. The Alien is bigger than the marine, but the legs are bent up while the Marine is stretched out.
If the alien's legs were stretched out, are they longer than the marine's?
The alien here always seemed too puny to me.
Posted by SiL
 - Mar 04, 2024, 12:51:14 PM
Quote from: Neila on Mar 04, 2024, 11:17:25 AMDoes anyone remember the bonus powerloader figure from A:CM?
the attacking alien warrior is much even smaller than the marine.
I'm looking at it now and it's not. The Alien is bigger than the marine, but the legs are bent up while the Marine is stretched out.
Posted by BlueMarsalis79
 - Mar 04, 2024, 11:52:50 AM
I can get not liking the Fireteam Elite Runner figure face area, I do not love it myself, but in size terms?

It still towers over most one tenth scale figures, just not to the degree of the Ultimate one, but the pose potential, the detail, the balance, the symmetry, the sculpt and paintjob outweigh the face being somewhat weird.
(Weird that they nailed it with the Prowler and Burster)

Look at the Ultimate from above and you can see the dome's literally f**king slanted to one side, it's so awful looking, look at the legs and arms being completely alternate sculpts, or the giant ball joints at the pelvis that comes further out to one side that the other.

It is just a poor representation of my favourite Alien.

If you do not like the Fireteam Elite Runner, I totally can get the reasons behind why, but that does not therefore make the Ultimate not a total mess because it absolutely is.


Posted by Neila
 - Mar 04, 2024, 11:17:25 AM
The size representation of the aliens in games, models and figures is often a problem.

Doggy wasn't always correct even in the film, even the makers say that.
By using the rod puppet in front of a blue screen, the creature was not always inserted correctly into the film and the size varied.(by the way: Neca ! I want a dog alien in size 1/4 !)

In the games the aliens are almost always too small for me.
The only ones who got it right were once again creative assembly.

In FE you can certainly try to explain this with the variation of the different mutations, but it doesn't look good either.
(I don't like this game anyway. a huge step backwards compared to isolation)

Does anyone remember the bonus powerloader figure from A:CM?
the attacking alien warrior is much even smaller than the marine.
No people, there are just too many fools out there messing around with the alien brand.

When the first AVP came out there was a photo behind the scenes. It showed Ian Whyte and Tom Woodruff, in their costumes, during a break from filming.
Tom is a lot smaller than Ian and many idiots at the time thought that this was the correct size for the creatures. I had magazines that said the alien warrior was about 1.80m tall.
which is absolute nonsense.
I'm just wondering why all the alien models don't have sneakers on, that was clearly visible in the picture... :'(

Posted by Xenomrph
 - Mar 04, 2024, 01:33:15 AM
The mouth on the FTE Runner looks awful and instantly kills the figure for me. I don't care if the Ultimate movie one is "less accurate", it looks better to my eyes, it's bigger so I feel like I'm getting a better value, the accessories were cooler (mainly because it had some), and I can get it in the poses I want to.
Posted by aliens13
 - Feb 27, 2024, 10:59:51 PM
Quote from: Still Collating... on Feb 27, 2024, 09:58:10 PMYes, it's accurate to the game, but not the movie versions. Neca's Runner was originally too big, but I'd rather get that than too small. The Fireteam ones are too small compared to the movie. You can say they're from smaller creatures on the planet, but they aren't the known Dog/Ox Alien. And again, the price per amount of plastic is an important factor. Ultimate Dog Alien was around 50$ with a bigger size of the figure and more accessories, while just the smaller Runner was around 60$. That is a huge deal.

And a personal minus for the initial design itself in FTE are the wide oversized hands (not too long fingers like in some designs, just having the palm of the hands be too wide), but that's not Neca's fault. What is their fault is taking away double jointed elbows.

The figure is nicely textured, but that's cause they used the ingame 3D files for the sculpt. That's great, if they do more game Aliens, I hope they use that technique. Too bad we couldn't have gotten an accurate Defiance Praetorian...

And why they didn't proceed to make the Drone, Warrior and Praetorian is beyond me. Maybe cause they just wanted to make the smaller overpriced Aliens instead of the bigger ones.   
I would have been cool if they made an "Monica" Alien Drone figure
Posted by Still Collating...
 - Feb 27, 2024, 09:58:10 PM
Yes, it's accurate to the game, but not the movie versions. Neca's Runner was originally too big, but I'd rather get that than too small. The Fireteam ones are too small compared to the movie. You can say they're from smaller creatures on the planet, but they aren't the known Dog/Ox Alien. And again, the price per amount of plastic is an important factor. Ultimate Dog Alien was around 50$ with a bigger size of the figure and more accessories, while just the smaller Runner was around 60$. That is a huge deal.

And a personal minus for the initial design itself in FTE are the wide oversized hands (not too long fingers like in some designs, just having the palm of the hands be too wide), but that's not Neca's fault. What is their fault is taking away double jointed elbows.

The figure is nicely textured, but that's cause they used the ingame 3D files for the sculpt. That's great, if they do more game Aliens, I hope they use that technique. Too bad we couldn't have gotten an accurate Defiance Praetorian...

And why they didn't proceed to make the Drone, Warrior and Praetorian is beyond me. Maybe cause they just wanted to make the smaller overpriced Aliens instead of the bigger ones.   
Posted by Sabres21768
 - Feb 27, 2024, 12:50:56 AM
Quote from: StayFrosty on Feb 25, 2024, 01:47:59 AMSo I finally got a hold of a Fireteam Elite Runner Alien. I'm very disappointed... too small, but mainly the Ultimate Dog alien looks much more realistic. Looks way better. Luckily I have both.

Ultimate Dog for the win!
It's actually accurate. The Dog Alien was never as big as portrayed by Neca. But more importantly, they're smaller in the game.
Posted by BlueMarsalis79
 - Feb 26, 2024, 10:29:19 PM
The accessories are good, the inaccuracies, and inability to pose it in running stances kills it. It can not even look horizontally or stand on all fours at once in a natural way.
Posted by Still Collating...
 - Feb 26, 2024, 10:17:00 PM
Still, I'm also on the vote that the Ultimate Dog Alien is better than the FTE one. The FTE one is overpriced, too small and the tail is too short. I know it's accurate to the game, but not to the movie. Its joints do seem sturdier, but the ones on the Ultimate aren't bad either. It's not like the first release. And with the ultimate that is in the worst case scenario the same price, but more often cheaper, you get a bigger figure, more visible detailed textures and 2 chestburster queens.
Posted by BlueMarsalis79
 - Feb 26, 2024, 08:00:36 PM
Only the head was slightly asymmetrical in the film itself, look up the ArtFX statue or CoolProps one for what it should look like.
AvPGalaxy: About | Contact | Cookie Policy | Manage Cookie Settings | Privacy Policy | Legal Info
Facebook Twitter Instagram YouTube Patreon RSS Feed
Contact: General Queries | Submit News