Well that's the pitfalls of fandom for you, you're never going to please absolutely everyone. I'm hoping for a solid film; a great film, even, it needn't be as great as Alien or Aliens, and I'm afraid lightening will not strike quite like that again, but if it's close that'd be fantastic. I know it's going to look fabulous, and has the potential to damn well put to shame every other film in the franchise sans the original in that respect, so a cautious optimism is reasonable. Let's see where they'll take us with this.