Alien 5 or Predator 3?

[Darkness]

Which film would want to see made the most and why? Alien 5 or Predator 3?

[The Ultimate Predator]

Predator 3, simply because I'm at heart a Predator fan. I also think that there is so much that has been left to discover with Predator, but with Alien, a lot has been done.

[Darkness]

I would have said Predator 3 before AvP came out but after what happened there, I want Alien 5. At least with Ridley Scott and Cameron at the helm, it'll be a quality film.

But yes, there's still lots to be done in the Predator series but I just think Fox will screw it up.

[The Ultimate Predator]

True, I'm just being optimistic, who knows what could happen?

[Corporal Hicks]

While Predator has so much left in it, I just want Ripley to be killed and a new door to be opened for Alien films.

[Darkness]

So you wouldn't want a prequel to the Alien series rather than a sequel to Res?

[Corporal Hicks]

I'd just as happily go back in time and forget Ripley all together.

[Milo Minderbinder]

Might be interesting to see a film with a Type III or IV civilisation coming up against aliens. Totally ditch the current background, like.

[Mystic Lemons]

I don't want them to make another Alien film. They'd only go and get it all wrong.

[Milo Minderbinder]

This is true. I think it's inevitable, though, given that the film industry mostly ran out of ideas about ten years ago.

[MrLee]

as much as i love alien series, they have had like more sequels, so id rather have another predator, only if it was good though.

[Corporal Hicks]

I think the films should be handed over to someone with talent. I mean, the reason A4 and AvP sucked ass are because A) Fox wanted Ripley which didn't give Whedon enough leg room, B)Fox wanted a quick cash in and gave it to someone who can't write for shit.

[Milo Minderbinder]

Whedon can write though, that's the thing. It's just that he has a particular style that doesn't fit in the Alien universe at all.

[Corporal Hicks]

B was aimed at AvP.  I know Whedon can write. Big fan of Firefly/Serenity here.

[The Ultimate Predator]

But it is unfortunately very rare for a film to be made just for sheer quality - not for money.