Double post because I wanted to do a little topic of the day. Hopefully we'll get some good convo about this.
Are you a Star Wars fan? Do you also enjoy strategy games and find the broad, galaxy-spanning theme of Star Wars to fit nicely with the game genre?
What is your dream Star Wars strategy game? In the past, we've gotten a few offerings, from the now-ancient Rebellion, to Force Commander, to the Age of Empires-like Galactic Battlegrounds, and the latest iteration: Empire at War with its expansion Forces of Corruption.
I've been enjoying Empire at War, but it's a bit too shallow and simple overall to really scratch my Star Wars itch. It makes up for this with amazing space battles and a decent galactic map with lots of different campaigns, but I miss a lot of the older things from games like Rebellion.
For example, the politics are basically non-existent in Empire at War. You simply mass units, move them around to control front lines and hyperspace lanes, and conquer everything. When I first played the campaign, I got kind of lost and then had my butt thoroughly kicked because I was trying to play like the real Rebels did in the films.
I thought hit-and-run tactics, spies, hiding, and politics would really be important. Sadly, outside of the campaign levels that take you through a sort of story, the game is very much 'conquer everything, build as much as possible, destroy, repeat.' There's no real subterfuge, little to do outside of basic army and fleet management, and your heroes are kind of limited compared to what they could do in an older game like Rebellion. In that game, you could send them off all over the galaxy to represent the Rebellion and win systems to your cause, through diplomatic or economic means. Each character had different strengths and weaknesses, and it was great.
Do you agree? Disagree? Would you rather be making a grilled cheese sandwich right now? Let's hear your thoughts, hopefully about Star Wars strategy games!