Scott says "Covenant is about mortality and immortality!!

[Ultramorph]

Nah, Sagardoa  called Guy Pearce and the name Walter months before anyone else. 4chan guy could have made it all up seeing the trailer and looking at the leaked pictures.

[Enoch]

Nah, Sagardoa  called Guy Pearce and the name Walter months before anyone else. 4chan guy could have made it all up seeing the trailer and looking at the leaked pictures.

Here, here.

There is a great chance for that scenario if you ask me.

[shawsbaby]

Nah, Sagardoa  called Guy Pearce and the name Walter months before anyone else. 4chan guy could have made it all up seeing the trailer and looking at the leaked pictures.

Right, that I know. I also know that a simple imdb inbox message to Sagardoa will confirm or deny if he and 4chan guy saw the same film, and well, the answer might disappoint you. Hence my confusion that their reports were at odds...

[Ephemer Nine]

When did the 4chan guy start posting his leaks? If it was post-trailer (not necessarily after the embargo ended, though, as he could have been present at the Showcase 2017 events), then the chances of it being fake go from very high to near certain (I'm much more relieved if that's the case).

[Enoch]

Somewhere around December 19.
Those test screening were held earlier. Hicks know that best.
Why did he wait that long to share the intel on 4chan?

[Ultramorph]

Anyone with an IMDB account want to just message Sagardoa and end the debate?

[shawsbaby]

Anyone with an IMDB account want to just message Sagardoa and end the debate?

I'm saying that I already did last week and he said the 4chan guy knew what he was talking about. And given that he knew the name Walter a long, long time ago as well as Shaw's fate (both of which he publicly posted on imdb), I assume he's telling the truth and the 4chan spoilers are in fact the film we're getting.

[Ultramorph]

Anyone with an IMDB account want to just message Sagardoa and end the debate?

I'm saying that I already did last week and he said the 4chan guy knew what he was talking about. And given that he knew the name Walter a long, long time ago as well as Shaw's fate (both of which he publicly posted on imdb), I assume he's telling the truth and the 4chan spoilers are in fact the film we're getting.

Oh, sorry for the confusion. That's a shame.

[shawsbaby]

I dont think you can message someone on IMDB

Of course you can!

So, the crashed ship remains a mystery I suppose but otherwise, I think we know how this movie is going to unfold.

Anyone with an IMDB account want to just message Sagardoa and end the debate?

I'm saying that I already did last week and he said the 4chan guy knew what he was talking about. And given that he knew the name Walter a long, long time ago as well as Shaw's fate (both of which he publicly posted on imdb), I assume he's telling the truth and the 4chan spoilers are in fact the film we're getting.

Oh, sorry for the confusion. That's a shame.

No problem. But that's why I've been so confused by the "fact" of the Juggernaut appearing crashed in the trailer somehow negating both 4chan guy and Sargadoa's accounts of the film.

[Enoch]

Are you Sagardoa, are you 4chan guy

I think they are the same person.
Why ask a liar about other liar

[anduu]

Well someone needs to do a point by point debunking of 4chan guy's statements.

From what I have seen there are points in there that were only seen when we got the trailer.

[shawsbaby]

Well someone needs to do a point by point debunking of 4chan guy's statements.

From what I have seen there are points in there that were only seen when we got the trailer.

I do agree that many of his recollections seem to be missing some narrative logic here and there. If it plays out exactly as he's detailed, then the script may indeed be problematic. Given how the ending seemed to confuse him, it's likely he was confused by other aspects of the film/wasn't paying close attention. So we'll see.

[Ultramorph]

Just messaged Sagardoa myself. Trust, but verify, 

[Enoch]

I dont believe any of those guys.

[shawsbaby]

I dont believe any of those guys.

Could be! I'm secretly hoping it's all a big lie. Would be great to be surprised in May