Quote from: Bojo on Apr 03, 2017, 12:13:40 PM
See the problem with the Xenomorph nowadays is,because its so embedded in popular culture,that the creature/design looks less frightening and more cool.
That's not a criticism of Scott it's just unfortunately the way it is.
That's the view Scott had, but it's completely false. What we've seen over the years in popular media are pale imitations of how to portray the Alien
correctly. When '
Alien Isolation' came out, the one thing it did superbly was to give us an Alien which looks and moves just like it should. It's probably the first time since '
Aliens' that the creature came across as the nightmarish living creature it's meant to be.
See, how many times have we seen vampires, dragons and zombies? There have been portrayals of those for
centuries and not just in attempts to do so seriously, but in comedy and mockery. Yet, that doesn't stop them from having the potential to be terrifyingly effective when someone does them
right.
Familiarity with a visual design will never detract from its power. You just have to know how to handle them. How to have them behave, what to have them do and, importantly, how to atmospherically light them (visually, lighting is probably the most effective tool of them all).
Otherwise, common old human beings would never be able to come across as scary. But the vast majority of films with villains in tend to be human.
Quote from: SiL on Apr 03, 2017, 01:08:55 PM
I agree that suits with enhancements is typically the best option. The fact every shot of the Alien so far has been CG, even in simple closeups, just really doesn't bode well. Even the test screenings said it was mostly CGI, which makes me think the practical stuff has been painted over completely.
I agree. The movement of the creature just doesn't have the weight needed to project the illusion of inertia. It's
too fluid, which makes me wonder if not only the practical suit effects have been mostly covered over, but that the actor's movements might have been permanently sped up for almost every shot, Benny Hill-style.
Someone should put Yakety Sax over the AC adverts and see if it improves them.
Quote from: Molecules on Apr 03, 2017, 01:36:39 PM
Mind you, for everything the Prometheus trailers and TV spots gave away, didn't they keep the trilobyte and deacon in the chamber?
Yeah, but they were relatively inconsequential to the film. The former didn't have much time on screen and the latter was almost a Roger Corman-alike wink-wink, nudge-nudge thing.