Prey vs Alien Romulus

Started by David, Aug 16, 2024, 06:32:54 PM

Which movie was better

Prey
Alien Romulus
Author
Prey vs Alien Romulus (Read 8,009 times)

David

David

I have not seen Alien Romulus yet so I will vote later.

Samhain13

Samhain13

#1
Huh tough one.

Spoiler
One we get Newborn 2.0
Other we get a inbred looking Predator loosing a fight vs a little pocahontas
[close]

BlueMarsalis79

BlueMarsalis79

#2
Prey easily.

CANNON

CANNON

#3
Prey.

And I know I've said this in almost every single other prey thread in the AvPG forum and I'll say it again here. In my opinion, when it comes to prey, I can ignore the different hunting styles, lack of intelligence and lack of key defining traits I associate to a predator, which JH had where Feral does not, but I cannot stress how the choice to use Feral's face design in lieu of Winston's iconic Predator design really took me out of the movie and made me feel as if I was watching a lesser type of monster movie than what could of been a solid Predator movie. At the very least even with Romulus, alien filmmakers may alter the Xeno's design slightly, but Gigers vision always remains as a constant and therefore treated with respect.

SiL

SiL

#4
Prey by a mile.

solace97

solace97

#5
Prey at least portrayed the terribly designed predator in a better fashion than what Alien Romulus did for the Alien.

There were amazing action and kill sequences in Prey making you be like how tf are they going to kill this thing?

The Alien was never a threat in Alien Romulus

CANNON

CANNON

#6
Quote from: solace97 on Aug 16, 2024, 09:04:55 PMPrey at least portrayed the terribly designed predator in a better fashion than what Alien Romulus did for the Alien.

There were amazing action and kill sequences in Prey making you be like how tf are they going to kill this thing?

The Alien was never a threat in Alien Romulus

Thats sound reasoning and I agree.

TheDerelict

TheDerelict

#7
I really like both. But airlocks and thick strands of drool is where my heart truly belongs.

Acid_Reign161

Acid_Reign161

#8
They are both fantastic, and both totally different kinds of movies, but Alien Romulus wins by far for me; 3rd viewing booked for tomorrow! 🤩

Janek

Janek

#9
Prey was great mind but Romulus for me is the better film in nearly every department. Masterfully crafted but I agree that the alien threat was sadly lacking.

BigChapismyBestFriend

BigChapismyBestFriend

#10
Yeah, I'll go with pray


Goddamnit, I misspelled.

Spoiler
Or did I?
pray with your lives.
[close]

DARIAS93

DARIAS93

#11
Sorry, my fellow Alien fans, but as much as I enjoyed Romulus, Prey easily surpasses it. I felt more connected with Naru and her brother than with any other character in Romulus, except for Andy.

thexenomorph

thexenomorph

#12
Both are great! I think Prey was the better made film, but my heart is with the Alien series and thus Romulus. 🙂

SM

SM

#13
Prey.

Scott Conover

Scott Conover

#14
Accidentally voted for Alien, but Prey for sure is the stronger film. I had fun with Romulus in a them park sorta way, but Prey has a fantastic lead, a great core story, an awesome setting and imaginative action. I also thought that the fan service was handled much better for the most part.

AvPGalaxy: About | Contact | Cookie Policy | Manage Cookie Settings | Privacy Policy | Legal Info
Facebook Twitter Instagram YouTube Patreon RSS Feed
Contact: General Queries | Submit News