AvPR vs A:R

[Rafael S.]

HAHAHAHAHA!
The question is just so...obvious...Requiem is the one!
They are both wrong but I just can't stand Ressurection and the Newborn.

[Horhey]

I wish Resurrection was never made and Joss Whedon would find another career cause he also f**ked up Wolverine during his Astonishing X-Men run.

[Ratchetcomand]

I know it takes place in the past but Apocalypto and even The Flintstones speak better then 10,000 BC.

When i saw apocalypto they didnt talk any english, and Flinstones isnt the most accurate source..

The Finstones part was just sarcasm. Apocalypto didn't speak english but at least they talk right and you can hear them porerly unlike 10,000 BC.

[Uncanny Antman]

Joss Whedon [...] also f**ked up Wolverine during his Astonishing X-Men run.

What, because the stories weren't all about Wolverine for a change?  Yeah, that was a real shame.   

[DoomRulz]

Gimme AvP:R over A:R any day of the week. I didn't understand A:R...what was the point of it??!

[Ratchetcomand]

Gimme AvP:R over A:R any day of the week. I didn't understand A:R...what was the point of it??!

I agee with you. I hated the aliens in the movie, they where so ulgy looking and too brown. I hate how they roar in the movie.

[Sol]

Where the hell's the option for "I like them both"?

[darthSnipe]

I say AVP: R simply because I fall asleep whenever watching Resurrection. Not a bad movie in it's own respect though, just the dialogue was a little dragged on. Alien and Aliens suffered from the same problem (10-20 minute conversations=snorefest).

[DoomRulz]

Gimme AvP:R over A:R any day of the week. I didn't understand A:R...what was the point of it??!

I agee with you. I hated the aliens in the movie, they where so ulgy looking and too brown. I hate how they roar in the movie.

My complaint isn't with the Aliens, my complaint lies with the whole film...it was campy, stupid, and completely destroyed Ripley's character.

[RumorControl]

Why are so many people saying that AR is a better film but then go on to vote for AvPR?

Come on, AvPR is on the same level as movies like Critters 4 and Troll 2.  AR is a masterpiece of cinema compared to it.

[darthSnipe]

Gimme AvP:R over A:R any day of the week. I didn't understand A:R...what was the point of it??!

I agee with you. I hated the aliens in the movie, they where so ulgy looking and too brown. I hate how they roar in the movie.

My complaint isn't with the Aliens, my complaint lies with the whole film...it was campy, stupid, and completely destroyed Ripley's character.

Getting off topic here...how exactly did it destroy her character?

The cloning gimmick was obviously a way to preserve Sigourney Weaver's character. That and the lackluster ending of Alien 3 with the queen "dying" with Ripley was so badly executed it screamed sequel.

[DoomRulz]

Gimme AvP:R over A:R any day of the week. I didn't understand A:R...what was the point of it??!

I agee with you. I hated the aliens in the movie, they where so ulgy looking and too brown. I hate how they roar in the movie.

My complaint isn't with the Aliens, my complaint lies with the whole film...it was campy, stupid, and completely destroyed Ripley's character.

Getting off topic here...how exactly did it destroy her character?

The cloning gimmick was obviously a way to preserve Sigourney Weaver's character. That and the lackluster ending of Alien 3 with the queen "dying" with Ripley was so badly executed it screamed sequel.

It wasn't b/c of the cloning. It was b/c the film transformed her from a badass soldier woman into a cliched sci-fi sexual female. Rememeber the scene where she, for all intents and purposes, starts rubbing herself against the floor and says "I can hear them..." then falls through the floor? I wanted to scream...

[darthSnipe]

Gimme AvP:R over A:R any day of the week. I didn't understand A:R...what was the point of it??!

I agee with you. I hated the aliens in the movie, they where so ulgy looking and too brown. I hate how they roar in the movie.

My complaint isn't with the Aliens, my complaint lies with the whole film...it was campy, stupid, and completely destroyed Ripley's character.

Getting off topic here...how exactly did it destroy her character?

The cloning gimmick was obviously a way to preserve Sigourney Weaver's character. That and the lackluster ending of Alien 3 with the queen "dying" with Ripley was so badly executed it screamed sequel.

It wasn't b/c of the cloning. It was b/c the film transformed her from a badass soldier woman into a cliched sci-fi sexual female. Rememeber the scene where she, for all intents and purposes, starts rubbing herself against the floor and says "I can hear them..." then falls through the floor? I wanted to scream...

Agreed. This was probably due to the genetic crossing of the Alien Queen and Ripley though.

[Ratchetcomand]

Come on, AvPR is on the same level as movies like Critters 4 and Troll 2. 

Are you serious? Those movies where crap and bad on every level. AVPR was ok but not bad as in worst movie ever level of Troll 2 or Batman & Robin.

I'm having a feeling that you have not seen Battlefield Earth or any movie from Uwe Boll (Like House of Dead and In the name of the King). AVPR is The Shawshank Redemption compre to those movies.

[That Yellow Alien]

It wasn't b/c of the cloning. It was b/c the film transformed her from a badass soldier woman into a cliched sci-fi sexual female. Rememeber the scene where she, for all intents and purposes, starts rubbing herself against the floor and says "I can hear them..." then falls through the floor? I wanted to scream...

Ripley was never a badass soldier woman...which is a cliche itself.