AVPR because f**k it. AVPR got overall below average to pure bad characters, The Predator got a few good ones but others that made so angry I facepalmed out of frustation on the theater, I wish the kid and Munn weren't in the movie.
I dislike the story of both and think they should have gone somewhere else but The Predator's changes to the Predator lore managed to somehow piss me off more than having aliens on a random town on the 21th Century and the Raccoon City ending rip off.
Both had predators I enjoyed watching, but Wolf lasts longer than the Fugitive, whose's movie plot ends up trashing the guy. And with that suit... to hell with that thing.