Stupidity of the Ego: In defence of Prometheus and Covenant

[Voodoo Magic]

Villeneuve. An AvP movie. No humans.

[kwisatz]

Sure, why not.

Runtime: 210 min.

[The Old One]

It's not necessary that it's him particular, in fact, I'd rather get a her in particular.

[Local Trouble]

Such as Lynne Ramsay, Mary Harron, Debra Granik, Jodie Foster, Julia Ducournau, Coralie Fargeat, Ana Lily Amirpour, Claire Denis - Jennifer Wexler & Anna Biller?

[Huggs]

He is at your house!

Spoiler

Right now!

[close]

Spoiler

Cuckoo!

[close]

[The Old One]

Such as, indeed.

[Kradan]

It's not necessary that it's him particular, in fact, I'd rather get a her in particular.

Spear Sisters ?

[viasqi]

if the pool is still going after reading 11 pages i'm casting my vote in to

- Prometheus - Lore acceptable
- Covenant is a at best a Ridley Scott brain fart

i don''t get how some are ok with Covenant but it's your choice to accept the explanation

i for one don't care what anyone says :

1. the spores from the Black Catalyst infused plants do NOT hold hands and start flying like a bird
2. David did NOT breed eggs out of his ass
3. Xenomorphs do not " dance " for androids

[The Old One]

Covenant's far superior to Prometheus. It's prologue alone's perfect.

[426Buddy]

Yeah I prefer AC for sure.

[SM]

2. David did NOT breed eggs out of his ass

Correct.  He most certainly did not breed anything "out of his ass".

[Evanus]

Ridley saved that for the last prequel lol

[David Weyland]

I'm clutching at straws but in pure comparison between the two, Prometheus feels more of a British film and Covenant a Hollywood film to me or Alien to Aliens type of difference

As theatre cuts, Covenant is a bit better but when you compare up the two best respective fan cuts (pseudo director cuts), Prometheus is IMO better

[SM]

We're comparing fan cuts as being legit now?

[Huggs]

2. David did NOT breed eggs out of his ass

Correct.  He most certainly did not breed anything "out of his ass".

Yeah, that one had me wondering if I'd missed a deleted scene.