Quote from: Sgt. Apone on Sep 24, 2012, 01:14:58 AMWell wasn't it supposed to be dream like? Dreams don't always make sense.
True but I think Fincher could have done that without redesigning the interior of the Sulaco and throwing an egg out of nowhere and so on.
Especially after Cameron meticulously recreated the Narcissus for his film.
Not to go on an angry rant, but remember the nightmare Ripley has in Aliens on the space station? What if that really happened? What if an Alien came out of nowhere, killed a character we grew to like in the last film, and the rest of the movie was basically a repeat of the first movie... that's what Alien 3 feels like to me.
Cameron did his own thing and I felt it worked creatively. He built on what Scott did. Fincher however threw what Cameron did away and tried to do his best Scott impression. Even if Fox hadn't given him crap I still think he was inexperienced for the job.