Amanda and Mclaren in Alien 5?

Started by THE CITY HUNTER, Sep 22, 2015, 12:51:02 PM

Good idea?

YES
6 (15%)
NOT SURE
10 (25%)
DON'T CARE
4 (10%)
NO
20 (50%)

Total Members Voted: 40

Author
Amanda and Mclaren in Alien 5? (Read 18,971 times)

THE CITY HUNTER

After doing some surfing on this website I found some fan art done by Nelostic (will post it below) and i was thinking what would you guys think of Amanda and Ripley being in Alien 5.The first problem is how?well posted a forum you can check Alternative ending in Alien 3 to go with Alien 5 what is your opinion? Here are the pictures:






𝔗𝔥𝔢 𝔈𝔦𝔤𝔥𝔱𝔥 𝔓𝔞𝔰𝔰𝔢𝔫𝔤𝔢𝔯

𝔗𝔥𝔢 𝔈𝔦𝔤𝔥𝔱𝔥 𝔓𝔞𝔰𝔰𝔢𝔫𝔤𝔢𝔯

#1
It's gonna be a wee bit tricky since Amanda has already died as an old woman by the time of Aliens. And if Burke told Ripley a little fib she's still gonna be a rickety ol' granny since this is evidently a sequel to Aliens. Nevermind the strong possibility that Alien 5 will likely be set an additional 30 years after Aliens

And no, just no to flashbacks, time travel or keeping Amanda in cryosleep and all that convoluted shit.







D. Compton Ambrose

Quote from: The Eighth Passenger on Sep 22, 2015, 06:21:09 PM
It's gonna be a wee bit tricky since Amanda has already died as an old woman by the time of Aliens. And if Burke told Ripley a little fib she's still gonna be a rickety ol' granny since this is evidently a sequel to Aliens. Nevermind the strong possibility that Alien 5 will likely be set an additional 30 years after Aliens

And no, just no to flashbacks, time travel or keeping Amanda in cryosleep and all that convoluted shit.

whiterabbit

How about no? :P

THE CITY HUNTER

Quote from: The Eighth Passenger on Sep 22, 2015, 06:21:09 PM
It's gonna be a wee bit tricky since Amanda has already died as an old woman by the time of Aliens. And if Burke told Ripley a little fib she's still gonna be a rickety ol' granny since this is evidently a sequel to Aliens. Nevermind the strong possibility that Alien 5 will likely be set an additional 30 years after Aliens

And no, just no to flashbacks, time travel or keeping Amanda in cryosleep and all that convoluted shit.
I agree with you

Whiskeybrewer

If they are going to do it, it needs to make sense, not be some sort of fanwank/convoluted plotline.

THE CITY HUNTER

Quote from: Whiskeybrewer on Sep 23, 2015, 01:38:15 PM
If they are going to do it, it needs to make sense, not be some sort of fanwank/convoluted plotline.
Its all about execution.

Whiskeybrewer

Quote from: THE CITY HUNTER on Sep 24, 2015, 02:14:07 PM
Quote from: Whiskeybrewer on Sep 23, 2015, 01:38:15 PM
If they are going to do it, it needs to make sense, not be some sort of fanwank/convoluted plotline.
Its all about execution.

exactly. Otherwise whats the point

Snark

Snark

#8
I thought it would have been nice to have her in a cameo where Ripley finds an old recording Amanda made after the Sevastopol incident. It would have been addressed to her mother explaining what happened while trying to search for her. It would have been buried deep within WY's archives and lead to her finding more disturbing truths about their involvement with the xenomorph. This could lead her to her teaming up with Hicks to put an end to WY's crazy projects or something like that.

irn

irn

#9
NO. The Ripley story arc finished with Alien 3. Constantly shoehorning in Ripley or a Ripley is just making the overall story ridiculous.

THE CITY HUNTER

Quote from: irn on Sep 24, 2015, 07:01:04 PM
NO. The Ripley story arc finished with Alien 3. Constantly shoehorning in Ripley or a Ripley is just making the overall story ridiculous.
I fear I typical happy ending.

HuDaFuK

HuDaFuK

#11
Quote from: irn on Sep 24, 2015, 07:01:04 PMNO. The Ripley story arc finished with Alien 3. Constantly shoehorning in Ripley or a Ripley is just making the overall story ridiculous.

You say that, but Amanda Ripley in Isolation actually worked. She wasn't shoehorned in, they came up with legitimate, totally logical reason for her to be involved, and I liked how she was portrayed.

Infected

Infected

#12
Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley...

So sick an tired of hearing this name and connecting it to the Alien franchise....just get rid of her!!!

Whiskeybrewer

Quote from: Snark on Sep 24, 2015, 04:37:18 PM
I thought it would have been nice to have her in a cameo where Ripley finds an old recording Amanda made after the Sevastopol incident. It would have been addressed to her mother explaining what happened while trying to search for her. It would have been buried deep within WY's archives and lead to her finding more disturbing truths about their involvement with the xenomorph. This could lead her to her teaming up with Hicks to put an end to WY's crazy projects or something like that.

To me that's the logical route, if they did have an appearance by Amanda in the film and say Alien 3 and 4 remain part of the universe (just a tiny possibility that I cling to sadly) having this one set between Aliens and Alien3, could add the emotion of 3 in the fact that Ripley becomes resind to WY's amorality

THE CITY HUNTER

Quote from: Infected on Sep 25, 2015, 09:25:06 AM
Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley Ripley...

So sick an tired of hearing this name and connecting it to the Alien franchise....just get rid of her!!!
Dont forget about the predator.

AvPGalaxy: About | Contact | Cookie Policy | Manage Cookie Settings | Privacy Policy | Legal Info
Facebook Twitter Instagram YouTube Patreon RSS Feed
Contact: General Queries | Submit News