Yes but there was clearly massive contradictions to what went before in the original films. So it's not dumb criticism, it's incredibly valid actually. The fact of the matter is covenant underperformed critically as well as commercially. If some people enjoyed the film good for them, but I think for a lot of us, we were severely disappointed with the final product. Even without bad scripts , the execution was still poor, and answering questions with questions only takes us so far before we start to switch of.