Come on guys! We have an Oscar winner actor headlining a Predator film! I like Brody and I think he's a good choice. And look on the bright side, at least it's not Adam Brody... As for Topher Grace. He's the last person you would ever expect to be in a Predator film and that's the idea! When you read the character descriptions, Edwin seems to be the last person you'd expect to be a worthly prey for a Predator. He's supposed to be the most unassuming and the weakling of the group, but in reality this guy's a sick bastard! He's the most dangerous, but you wouldn't know it just by looking at him, and with the right script and the right director (which I'm sure we have both) I think Topher can pull it off.