Hunter's Planet was the book I preferred of the two. I did wish however that Dark Horse adapted it into comic form. Mainly to see Levinston's creations, the Buggers, the genetically engineered Alien-cyborgs. Hell, if the powers that be at 20th Century Fox decide to go for AVP 3, set the flick in the future with them. The Buggers seem to be what Weyland-Yutani ,and the military have been wanting to do with the Alien since the very first flick.