I apologize, Mr. Perry, if I have in effect offended you in some way. I suppose I was a bit flustered and, in turn, I was unable to express myself as eloquently as I would have liked. If you would be so kind as to hear me out once more, I would like to rephrase my initial sentiments.
Quote from: steveperry on Sep 11, 2008, 06:10:28 PM
The notion that I can't pronounce a word that I made up any way that I want is, not to put too fine a point on it, silly.
I didn't mean to insinuate you having an inability to pronounce a word of your own creation. I was honestly just asking a question.
[/quote]
For me to try and write material that is at odds with what I believe wouldn't work very well. The German Shepherd Dog comparison pissed a lot of people off because they don't agree, and I can understand that, but since that's what I believe, and I'm the guy putting the words through my fingers for people who believe the same thing, what would you have me do? Jettison my opinion and adopt yours?
Uh, no. My opinion might not be any more valid, but it
is mine, and since nobody has put forth any convincing reason why I should dump it and take up theirs, why would I? You think I'm wrong? Fine, no problem. I think I'm right, and I'm the guy who gets to say it in print. If you really have a case you think is watertight, take it to Fox and change their minds. [/quote]
I fully respect your opinion. I guess a better representation of my "point" would be akin to what Xenomrph alluded to after my last post. How much do the fans influence your work? I understand that your opinion trumps all others, but have you ever thought "Hmmm... maybe, despite my views, I should throw something in there for the Alien fans." ? I remember reading "Prey" when I was a considerably young Alien newcomer and thinking - When are the Aliens going to get their turn? - only for it to never come. I can't argue with your idea that an Alien is no match for a Predator, but if that's so, why even have a crossover? What's the point of having such a thrilling title such as AVP, if the content is more like 'humans face a dire dilemma as Predators kill Aliens'? I wouldn't write a book about Polar Bears fighting Penguins, mostly because I don't see that as much of a match. So, I guess I don't really see your point.
[/quote]
If you can do better, you have my blessing to try.
[/quote]
In an extended universe comprised of such a motley of viewpoints, I doubt I could do better. But, perhaps in my own way, just as good?