Quote from: steveperry on May 27, 2007, 05:57:39 PM
Well, my position is pretty obvious. I thought Alien looked great, but it was an idiot-plot and I wasn't impressed with it. Walter Hill is a great producer. Not a writer. His taste in cheese is different than mine.
Which is why I think A2 was a better movie -- Cameron likes skiffy and it shows.
Well, if we're gonna talk about idiot plots, I think
Aliens would easily rank up there with the best. It's a great lesson in how to dumb everything down, from your main characters to your enemy, for the sole purpose of having a particular scene -- In this case, Ripley saving Newt.
If it had been competent, fully armed marines that were taken out by the Aliens, then Ripley going in single-handed would've been even more ridiculous. Cameron had to completely disarm his marines for the first fight, making the Aliens all the less imposing when you finally realise that the Aliens are, for all intents and purposes, taking out darn-near unarmed opponents.
Which means they aren't so dangerous after all. Which means a woman lugging around two heavy guns with five minutes' worth of training can go into the hive and do considerable amounts of damage without getting a scratch on her.