You know, the first AVP movie was good on paper. It just had really shitty unmemorable characters. The action was solid despite it lacking gore, had great practical effects for suits and miniature models, and was just shy of being a big summer action movie. Requiem I feel if handled by Anderson would had been a lot better. Their wouldn't have been any of this darkness problem, and I think he would have looked for better actors after the reaction of the first movie. I think more moments from the comics would be implemented into the script, as per the first one did. Would it have been a good movie? Maybe not, but it would have been better than what was given.