Quote from: RakaiThwei on Feb 28, 2015, 06:00:51 AM
According to this Calendar: http://www.worldtimeserver.com/calendar.aspx?y=2179
And of course SM's Alien timeline: http://timeline.alienexperience.com/2127to2179.html
There is a span of twelve days from July 28th 2179 to August 8th, 2179. Technically speaking, something COULD theoretically happen within a span of twelve days.
Seriously?
I admire the effort and its a good fun read, but this stuff is really splitting hairs. Deductive reasoning, being skillful or not, it's fan fiction.
The novelisation says this, an early draft of a script may have said that... Cool. Great to read this. But it's not meant to be this precise because the movies are made for mass audiences not obsessed fans like we all are. Haha. Don't get me wrong, I LOVE IT. But that's me - a massive Alien nerd.
At a certain point you need to suspend disbelief and admit that its a sci-fi movie and the details don't need to be this absolute. That said, they don't need to be disrespected and retconned either.
I think the lack of clarity in this area (who, what, when and where), especially in Alien 3, sets the tone correctly. The less this stuff is clarified the better. It makes space that much more unsettling IMO anyway. But then again, I always felt A3 started off the way it did to suggest there was a greater story we didn't know about yet (which Prometheus and A:CM and A:I all further contribute to) and I actually LIKED that idea. Which, is something I've never, ever, understood fan reactions to... Why can't people accept the idea that they are only seeing a piece of a larger puzzle? I dunno. Why does everything need to be in this neat package? It's the same thing in Aliens. Some people think Burke was acting alone. In a sense I agree but I also think there was clearly a cover up somewhere and someone knew something whetehr those are the people Ripley interacted with or not. Big Brother was watching... I specifically mean to say; These aren't questions I want answers to. The proposed answers we all give support to, should be tempered as ruminations. Just ruminations. And what happens when you start trying to line up all these dominos that aren't meant to be lined up, is you end up butting heads with future additions to the story because you forced everything to work out in your mind based on limited information and because we all became attached to certain things we liked and/or did not like...
This stuff needs to be taken with a grain of salt, yes. But this is also why retcons are terrible things.