The Lord Of The Rings: The Two Towers (Extended Edition, viewed last weekend)
I could on and on about how disorganized this was from the book, but, it Is a movie. Still an awesome movie, with the battle scenes being the best from all three films imo.
9/10
The Lord Of The Rings: The Return Of the King (Extended Edition)
I remember hoping how this was going to be the greatest of the three back in 2003, keep wishing. I think what rattles me the most is
Spoiler
where The Two Towers ends in the book is almost 3/4 into this film (Frodo is taken by the enemy). Also, waltzing through Mordor never happened. It was pure torture and ultra slow, also Frodo and Sam were naked. Additionally, Saruman goes to the Shire and takes over (for the most part), not being murdered by Grima Wormtongue on top of Orthanc. So the hobbits had to take back the Shire from "Sharku" (old man), marking a battle post-Mordor downfall.
Like TTT, a great movie nonetheless, but miles away from the book's contents. The extended edition's scenes (especially with The Army Of The Dead) are at points it's redeeming quality.
8/10